Key Takeaways
Courts will take a contextual approach to interpreting termination provisions in wrongful dismissal cases governed by the Canada Labour Code (CLC), a new decision by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice confirms.
Employees often pick apart the wording of a termination provision to argue that it shortchanges their minimum entitlements under the law. In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice read an employment contract in context and held that its termination provision complied with the CLC. The court applied Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc., 2026 ONCA 568, which asks what the parties objectively intended, based on the contract as a whole and the circumstances around it.
Background
The Batchewana First Nation of Ojibways (BFN) hired Ms. Henshell as its Chief Executive Officer in May 2024. About 11 weeks later, during her six-month probationary period, BFN ended her employment without cause.
Ms. Henshell brought two notable claims related to her end of employment: (1) wrongful dismissal and (2) moral damages for the manner of dismissal. BFN asked the court to uphold the termination provision and dismiss the claim at an early stage, through a motion under Rule 21 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.
Employment Agreement Interpreted as a Whole
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice upheld the termination provision. Ms. Henshell was not entitled to the longer notice period available at common law. The provision allowed BFN to terminate her “for any lawful reason” as long as it gave her what the CLC requires.
Ms. Henshell argued that a separate clause in the Rules and Regulations section of her employment agreement made the termination provision unenforceable. That clause stated that “any breach of the confidentiality of information policies or procedures which are in effect from time to time will be cause for severe discipline and/or termination of employment for cause.”
Ms. Henshell interpreted this clause to mean that she could be terminated for cause, without statutory entitlements, for any breach of confidentiality, regardless of the policies in effect at the time. Since this interpretation would violate the CLC, she argued that the termination provision was invalid.
The court rejected Ms. Henshell’s interpretation. It accepted that her reading might be plausible if the words were read literally and in isolation. However, the court followed Baker and read the contract as a whole, in context, to determine what the parties objectively intended.
The court considered the wording: the word “or” in “and/or” shows that not every breach of confidentiality leads to termination for cause. The court also considered the context: Ms. Henshell had been practising law for 20 years before her employment with BFN and would not have agreed to give up her rights under the CLC. The court also considered the contract as a whole: the termination provision’s clear language stated its intention to fully comply with the CLC. Read together, the two clauses mean that any for-cause termination for a confidentiality breach must still be lawful and comply with the CLC.
Considering these factors and the entire contract, the court upheld the termination provision.
The Court Also Dismissed the Employee’s Moral Damages Claim
The Court also rejected Ms. Henshell’s claim for moral damages arising from the manner of her dismissal. Importantly, an enforceable termination provision does not prevent an employee from claiming moral damages where an employer acts in bad faith in the dismissal process, such as by being untruthful, misleading or unduly insensitive.
However, the Court found that Ms. Henshell’s allegations did not meet that standard. Although she alleged that BFN terminated her employment after she raised concerns about potential financial misappropriation, the Court distinguished an employer’s reason for dismissal from its manner of dismissal. The allegations did not establish dishonest, misleading or otherwise bad\-faith conduct in carrying out the termination. The Court therefore struck the claim, including the moral damages claim, without leave to amend.
What This Means for Employers
Context matters when courts read termination provisions. Despite some recent ambiguity, this decision reinforces the Ontario Court of Appeal’s recent direction in Baker that termination provisions should be interpreted as part of the employment agreement as a whole, rather than through a technical and manufactured search for problematic words or phrases viewed in isolation. Although Henshell involved the Canada Labour Code, the Court expressly applied the interpretive framework developed in Baker in the Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000 context. For employers, the decisions underscore the importance of drafting termination provisions that, read as a whole, clearly demonstrate an intention to comply with applicable minimum employment standards.
An enforceable termination provision does not eliminate all dismissal-related exposure. Even where an employee’s entitlement to common-law reasonable notice has been validly excluded, an employee may still pursue moral damages based on an employer’s conduct in the manner of dismissal. Employers should therefore continue to carry out terminations honestly, sensitively and in good faith.
Special thanks to our articling student Brianna Grieff for contributing to this update.








